Home / McDonald Interviews / Montross, Nathaniel

Montross, Nathaniel

John M. McDonald interview — 1848-10-17

From the Westchester County Historical Society catalog:
Too young to participate in the Revolutionary War, Nathaniel Montross (1770-1858) later served as a general in the New York State Militia and a member of the New York State Assembly. He recalls the raid conducted by a British force commanded by Banastre Tarleton against Crompond on June 24, 1779, and mentions the killing of American soldier John Shaw and the burning of the Presbyterian church at Crompond. Montross then recounts how his father, David Montross, encountered a British force under Colonel John Graves Simcoe and was wounded “without provocation” by a British soldier. Hearing of this, Simcoe protected David Montross and sent his surgeon to treat him. Nathaniel Montross also describes the route taken by the Refugees on their withdrawal following the Battle of Pines Bridge. He concludes by describing several houses in the neighborhood around Pines Bridge, and discusses Jack, an enslaved man who was manumitted by his father.

Original findings from this interview

'Master, freedom is a great thing — I feel it here' — Jack's manumission
Nathaniel Montross records a direct quote from Jack, an enslaved man owned by his father David Montross. When offered freedom after age 50 with the advice to stay on the farm for security, Jack 'answered by putting his hand on his breast and saying, "Master, freedom is a great thing — I feel it here." He was made free, but didn't do well, because sick, and was supported by us at great expenses.' One of very few direct quotations from an enslaved Westchester resident in any period source.
→ See 07 Slavery Patriots Manor
Simcoe orders his own surgeon to treat a Loyalist civilian he mistakenly wounded
'My father encountered a British force under Colonel John Graves Simcoe and was wounded without provocation by a British soldier.' David Montross had taken an oath not to bear arms against the King; a Simcoe dragoon nonetheless cut him three times — back-of-sword to the chest, forehead, and finger-severing blow. Simcoe personally intervened, protected Montross, and sent his surgeon to treat him at Pines Bridge. Simcoe's reputation as the Queen's Rangers' tactical commander is well-documented; this personal mercy is not.

Manuscript page facsimiles

High-resolution images served from the Westchester County Historical Society's IIIF endpoint. Click any page to view full size.

Transcription

41.

October 17th. Genl Nathaniel Mon=tross aged seventyeight: "When Tarleton came out to Crompond in 1779, he crossed the Croton at Cudney's ford two and a half miles above Pines Bridge. He then went about two miles on the Somers road where they took Captain Teller whose company was at Crompond that day on duty, and who had been home that night on a visit to his wife. They then proceeded to pro=ceeded to Crompond with Teller riding in front to deceive the Americans. When they approached the enemy at Crompond his (Teller's) men said: "Who are there coming? Why there's the Captain with some of Sheldon's horse— Why there's Cap=tain Teller— They must be our folks," &c From Teller's house they took a circuitious road which came out into

doing him any further injury and rescued him. My father went home but finding himself badly wounded made for his sisters who lived just across Pines Bridge — that is south of it. He fainted on the bridge and his sister sent a person to his assistance. Simcoe who by this time had returned, then sent his Surgeon who cut the skin that held his little finger on, dressed that and his wound in the forehead and he soon recovered. Three cuts were made at him, one with the back of the sword, one on the forehead, and the other aimed at his head he fended off with his arm, and received the blow which cut off his finger. My father was a Captain under the King and advised not to bear arms against him.

Joseph McKul was a native of Yorktown and lived on the north side

of the river. Joshua Hughson also from the same neighborhood. My father's name was David He was a Captain before the Revolutionary war, and always said that his oath would always prevent him from taking up arms against the King).

The road or path through the woods by which the Refugees retreated from Davenports, came out into the Pines Bridge and Crompond road about a quarter of a mile north west of the Spook-Rocks, and about a quarter of a mile south east of Mr. Nathl Under hills. The road that leads to Joshua Carpenters is the same that led to Davenports in the Revolutionary war. The course of this road or path through woods is still perceptible at the point where it came out into the Crompond road.

My father lived about three fourths of a mile from Pines Bridge upon the Somers road. The widow Griffen lived on the Crompond road not more than a quarter of a mile from the Bridge. The widow Remsen lived between my fathers and the widow Griffen. A large white house on the north side of the Somers road now indicates the site of my fathers dwelling.

When Jack was upwards of fifty, my father offered him freedom but advised him to remain on the farm and he should be well supported in his old age. Jack answered by putting his hand on his breast and saying, "Master, freedom is a great thing — I feel it here." He was made free, but didn't do well, because sick, and was supported by us at great expenses.